Post-Mortem of Success: Questions that Drive Sustained Results

September 18, 2012 — 7 Comments

iStock 000008506568XSmall 294x300 Post Mortem of Success: Questions that Drive Sustained Results

Most great project managers know that it’s important to do a post-mortem after any major undertaking.   In my experience, a post-mortem is much more likely to occur when something went terribly wrong.  I have heard (and said) in the heat of frustration, “we just need to get through this now, but afterwards we need a very careful post-mortem.”

In this funny and insightful post, Lee Cash, shares the challenges with a traditional post-mortem and how to overcome some of them, The postmortem:  what it is and how to survive one.

Postmortem: noun:

  1. An examination and dissection of a dead body to determine cause of death or the changes produced by disease
  2. Discussion of an event after it has occurred
  3. A blame fest where, if you’re not careful, you get attributed with everything that’s wrong in the world

In essence, post-mortems are an attempt to review a recent calamity that has befallen the business with the noble intention of isolating the offending causes and making sure they never happen again. The practice nearly always takes the format of a face-to-face meeting (if possible) and involves all of the key players who had a role in the “hiccup”, and hence why you’re all now sitting in a room waiting for the fireworks to happen.

The post-mortem seems less urgent after an over-whelming success.  Most of us just celebrate, and then merrily race off to fight our next crises, or build our next remedial action plan.

Why Do a Post-Mortem of Success?

I recently had a celebratory conversation with a leader who was experiencing some fantastic results after months of challenges and struggling metrics.  This was turnaround at it’s finest.   I was delighted with the progress and wanted to recognize him. We did all that… and then… I asked, “what is working and why?”

That’s where we got stumped.

He had theories, I had theories… The truth is,  so many action plans and efforts had been applied to the problem, we were unsure of which were contributing to the solution.

A bit scary….Was it the entire cocktail?
…How do we isolate the variables?
…How would we sustain the progress if we didn’t understand what had worked?
…How could the lessons be applied to other areas of the business if we didn’t understand them?

How to Approach a Success Post-Mortem

We decided a deliberate approach was in order.  Yup, I ended that celebratory meeting by giving the guy more work. Why, because I believe in the long-run it will save everyone time.

He’s spending time…

  • considering and discussing... what were the expected outcomes of the various interventions?
  • observing:  what behaviors have actually changed?
  • measuring:  doing deeper dives into the analytics to look for patterns of improvement
  • listening:  to folks about what feels better now and why?

Taking the time to understand what is working may be even more vital than learning from our failures.

See also:  Failing Better:  Please Help Me Fail

Please comment: What techniques do you use to learn from your successes?

Do you like Let’s Grow Leaders?  Please help spread the word by subscribing (via email or RSS), commenting, sharing and tweeting.  Thank you!

7 responses to Post-Mortem of Success: Questions that Drive Sustained Results

  1. People tend to focus on the negatives first. They’re not negatives. The team did a really good job on how not to be successful with this project! Celebrate man!

    Sir James Dyson’s engineering team made 5,127 prototypes before they found “the” one vacuum cleaner that went to market.

    I say to clients, “The first one to make 5K mistakes wins.”

  2. Thought provoking post. We do tend to ignore the reason why we were successful. Perhaps because it is enticing to think of success as the natural byproduct of hard work and what should happen.

    That the only reason for poor results is poor execution.

    Perhaps some fields (science) accept that success will be rare while others (management) seem to think that success should be the norm.

  3. I have to be honest. This post really solidified for me that it’s time to sit down with my team and others who have been involved with the success of our project. Many times we dont take a moment to reflect, gather succeses and opportunities and document them.

    I’ve always encoraged my team to reflect and at times we have, but its that time again.

Trackbacks and Pingbacks:

  1. The Obvious Question: And How to Get It Right - October 15, 2012

    [...] Post-Mortem of Success:  Questions That Drive Sustained Results [...]

Leave a Reply

Text formatting is available via select HTML. <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>