Strong Performance Can Hide a Pending Exit
Why high performers leave when they’re succeeding—and how courageous leaders retain top talent early.
You don’t only lose your best people when something is broken.
Sometimes you lose them when everything looks fine.
Results are strong.
Customers are happy.
Their teams are engaged.
They’re exceeding expectations. You might have just recognized them with a big award or bonus.
And then they resign.
Not because they were failing.
Or because they were disengaged.
No signs of “quiet quitting.”
They were succeeding.
I’ve been on both sides of this.
I left Verizon at the top of my game. Rated “exceeds expectations.” Strong team. Strong results. From the outside, it made no sense.
But there were important values clashes we weren’t talking about.
If you want to understand why high performers leave when they’re still succeeding, you have to look beneath performance.
Because performance can mask erosion.
High Performance Can Hide Misalignment (with Video)
High performers care deeply about their work.
They want:
-
Meaning
-
Growth
-
Fairness
-
Challenge
-
A voice
Download FREE sample chapters
In Courageous Cultures, we talk about how silence spreads when people don’t believe their input matters. High performers are often the first to notice when:
-
Decisions feel political.
-
Values feel compromised.
-
Innovation slows.
-
Development stalls.
They don’t always raise a red flag.
They adjust.
>They deliver.
>They quietly evaluate their options.
And because they’re still performing, leaders miss the early signals.
Build Trust Before There’s a Problem
If you want to retain high performers, relationship depth matters long before disengagement shows up.
Not quarterly reviews.
Not surface-level check-ins.
Real conversations.
Instead of:
“Everything good?”
Try:
-
“What’s frustrating you that we haven’t talked about?”
-
“Where are you feeling out of alignment?”
-
“What would make this role even more compelling?”
In Powerful Phrases for Dealing with Workplace Conflict, we emphasize reducing interpersonal risk. High performers won’t surface concerns if they believe it could jeopardize their standing.
Retention begins with safety.
Ask the Question That Feels Risky
This question takes courage:
“If you were thinking about leaving someday, what would drive that?”
You’re not planting an idea.
You’re surfacing one that may already be there.
-
Values clashes
-
Perceived injustice
-
Burnout masked by competence
-
Boredom masked by productivity
-
Limited growth runway
You won’t prevent every departure.
But you will prevent the preventable ones.
Keep Growth Visible
High performers don’t just want to succeed.
They want to evolve.
When growth slows, they start imagining what’s next.
Ask:
-
“What would stretch you this year?”
-
“What would light you up?”
-
“What skills do you want to build next?”
Retention isn’t about comfort.
It’s about forward momentum.
Erosion Is Subtle
Standing at the 12 Apostles in Australia, watching those massive rock formations gradually erode into the ocean, I was reminded how strong things don’t disappear overnight.
They shift slowly.
High performer turnover works the same way.
You rarely lose everyone at once.
You lose them one by one.
Unless you notice the subtle signs early.
Practical Courage in Retention
Retaining high performers who are still succeeding requires:
-
Ongoing relational investment
-
Courageous questions
-
Willingness to hear uncomfortable truths
-
Intentional development
You can’t control every career move.
But you can create an environment where your strongest contributors want to stay.
And that takes courage.
In this week’s Asking for a Friend, I share three practical ways to keep high performers from slipping away — even while they’re delivering strong results.
What have you found most effective in keeping your strongest contributors engaged and growing?
0 Comments