A Question of Intimidation: Questions that Shut People Down

October 2, 2012 — 9 Comments

iStock 000019827119XSmall 235x300 A Question of Intimidation:  Questions that Shut People DownQuestions are powerful.  They can motivate, and inspire deeper thinking.

Great questions empower.

Questions can also intimidate, frustrate and shut down people down.

The most dangerous are those where the leader already  “knows” the answer… and is looking to see if the person will “get it right.”  Closed ended questions can have a similar impact, if the leader only wants to hear “yes” or “no.”

Such “tests” may have their occasional place in ops reviews and interviews, but the side effects can be deadly as a general leadership practice.

Questions that Intimidate and Disengage:

These questions seem to rear their ugly heads most frequently under times of stress and urgency… precisely when more calm and creative thinking would be most beneficial.

  • What do I have to do to get you to…
  • Why did you do that?
  • Did I ask you to do that?
  • Is that really working?
  • What is your experience in this area?
  • Who gave you the authority to make that decision?
  • Is that your final decision?
  • Are you sure about that?
  • What makes you think that will work?
  • ???

In Dan Rockwell’s post, Too Many Questions, he shares that teams asking “too many questions” can be a symptom of a micromanaging leader.  He shares too many questions can come from “delegating tasks versus results, vision and resources.”

If employees are intimidated or fearful, they may ask questions in order to keep from “getting it wrong.”   In that environment, the leader is limiting herself to her own thinking.  Such leadership diminishes the current scene and future team functioning.

It’s a cycle.  If a leader asks too many closed-ended or intimidating questions, the team gets scared…. and starts asking more questions to ensure they get it “right.”  The sad truth is that this cycle limits creativity and diminishes productivity.  In this case, only one brain is really doing the thinking.

Please comment and share:  

What questions do you find most intimidating?  What questions have you seen shut people down?

See also:  5 Ways Leaders Bust Confidence

Stupid Feedback:  When Stupid Smarts and What to Do About It

Subscribe to Let's Grow Leaders!
Never miss a blog post.

It's free, thought-provoking, and practical. Rest assured that I will never sell your e-mail address.

9 responses to A Question of Intimidation: Questions that Shut People Down

  1. Great post and so very true. I struggled with this during my first tenure as a team leader, asking ALL the wrong questions. As a result, not only did I shut down my team, I completely lost their trust and willingness to perform. It was was a tough and costly lesson, but I did learn from it.

    Moving forward as a leader, I began using questions that opened people up and showed that I valued their thoughts and input. Needless to say that approach was far more effective as my team really became invested in everything we were doing and owned the results.

  2. Great post. This makes me think of how I ask questions to my 7 year old. The questions communicate a message- not just a query.

  3. Questions that shut people down are leading ones and closed ended ones. Your disengaged questions can easily be turned around so they’re engaging. For example, “What do I have to do to get you to” can be modified to say “Who would you like to show up as so you feel great about this project?”

  4. I like this post and I agree many questions can be disengaging. In particular – leading questions like: “Don’t you agree that…” or “Isn’t it obvious that…” followed by an opinion or an assumed obvious response mostly make me want to exit a conversation.

  5. Thanks for joining the conversation. You provide some great examples here.

Trackbacks and Pingbacks:

  1. Humility and Leadership: Can We Teach Leaders to be Humble? - March 19, 2013

    [...] enough to not need to talk about it. 2. Teach the Art of Great Questions:  Teach the art of provocative questions.   Teach the power of pause.  Ask your own questions “what does your team think about this [...]

Leave a Reply

Text formatting is available via select HTML. <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>